View Single Post
Old 01-05-2006, 04:48 PM   #10
bigpiney
Senior Member
 
bigpiney's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Big Pine , CA
Posts: 842
bigpiney
Send a message via AIM to bigpiney
Default I could care less about either team also

But I thought it was incomplete from the beginning. It just seemed to me that he never had possession. One of his hands, I recall it to be his right, never stopped moving on the ball and I thought never had any control on the ball. It was like he was caressing the ball, but didn't secure it with that hand.

THat was my reaction to seeing the play the first time and it was reinforced after seeing the replay. But of course I was looking for that.

Maybe college needs to redefine what a catch is, like they did in the NFL. Because in college you can make a catch with one foot in bounds, but if you only got one foot down and then you got popped and the ball came loose they would probably rule it an incompletion. What a 'football move' is up to interpretation as well

Too bad the officials from the Penn State - FSU game couldn't have done the Rose Bowl instead. I thought they called a good game.
bigpiney is offline   Reply With Quote