Torture update from Gitmo

[Cali Coug]

Originally Posted by Tex

I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt, like any reasonable person would do. You are not that person.



Another bad analogy. You're arguing that imprisonment itself is de facto poor treatment, which is a separate discussion that you insist on conflating with this one. I'll help you out and start a new thread where you can pontificate on that topic.

As to this one, a reasonable person would evaluate how the detainees are being treated compared to (1) what is considered humane generally, and (2) what is typical for an enemy combatant. All the evidence, from this woman and from others, points to the conclusion that the US is exceeding the standard on both counts.

I'm not assuming anything of the sort (where are you even getting that from)? Please answer the question posed in my analogy.