What beat TCU in 2006 was John Beck's accuracy

[smokymountainrain]

Originally Posted by TheAzzuri

I agree with you for the most part, but I think Max Hall will have to step it up a notch for a win.

You make good points. I'm confident Hall will indeed step it up a notch - I'm not as confident that BYU will win the game as I think the defense might allow 25-30 points, but Hall, being the gamer he is, will play very well.

[TheAzzuri]

Originally Posted by smokymountainrain

You make good points. I'm confident Hall will indeed step it up a notch - I'm not as confident that BYU will win the game as I think the defense might and allow 25-30 points, but Hall, being the gamer he is, will play very well.

I edited it a little, but we still mostly agree.
________
Kitchen Measures

[il Padrino Ute]

Originally Posted by smokymountainrain

You make good points. I'm confident Hall will indeed step it up a notch - I'm not as confident that BYU will win the game as I think the defense might allow 25-30 points, but Hall, being the gamer he is, will play very well.

I don't know if TCU can win scoring 25-30 points. TCU has very good speed on defense, but BYU can score a ton of points on anybody. The only way I see TCU scoring that much and winning is if they hold the ball for several long drives that result in scores and the defense somehow slows down BYU's offense.

TCU's best chance to win is a low scoring game. They have to keep the BYU's offense off the field.

[Indy Coug]

Originally Posted by smokymountainrain

Hall is a better QB than Beck. We can talk arm strength, accuracy, whatever - the fact is, Hall is just a better QB.

Based on what?

[smokymountainrain]

Originally Posted by Indy Coug

Based on what?

Toughness, the willingness to stand in the pocket and take a hit if necessary, football IQ, the ability to see the field, and yes, I believe he is more accurate.

That and the fact that his passer rating is better than Becks ever was and Beck never started a season 6-0, nor was he able to go 11-2 as a sophomore.

You might say Hall has a better supporting cast, but that would be your opinion and mere excuses, shown in the above paragraph are the facts of the case and they cannot be disputed.

[Hot Lunch]

Originally Posted by smokymountainrain

Toughness, the willingness to stand in the pocket and take a hit if necessary, football IQ, the ability to see the field, and yes, I believe he is more accurate.

That and the fact that his passer rating is better than Becks ever was and Beck never started a season 6-0, nor was he able to go 11-2 as a sophomore.

You might say Hall has a better supporting cast, but that would be your opinion and mere excuses, shown in the above paragraph are the facts of the case and they cannot be disputed.

Let me explain this easily.... Max has a pair between his legs and Beck didn't. I would take Max as my quarterback over Beck without even thinking twice about it.

[Indy Coug]

Originally Posted by smokymountainrain

Toughness, the willingness to stand in the pocket and take a hit if necessary, football IQ, the ability to see the field, and yes, I believe he is more accurate.

That and the fact that his passer rating is better than Becks ever was and Beck never started a season 6-0, nor was he able to go 11-2 as a sophomore.

You might say Hall has a better supporting cast, but that would be your opinion and mere excuses, shown in the above paragraph are the facts of the case and they cannot be disputed.

Which is the same stupid rationale that got you claiming that Vince Young was all that and a bag of chips during his rookie season at Tennessee. Glad to see you haven't learned from the mistakes of the past.

[smokymountainrain]

Originally Posted by Indy Coug

Which is the same stupid rationale that got you claiming that Vince Young was all that and a bag of chips during his rookie season at Tennessee. Glad to see you haven't learned from the mistakes of the past.

With VY, the talent was there, but obviously the mental part left a lot to be desired. With Hall, his head may be his greatest strength. Especially in comparison with Beck.

[TheAzzuri]

Originally Posted by Hot Lunch

Let me explain this easily.... Max has a pair between his legs and Beck didn't. I would take Max as my quarterback over Beck without even thinking twice about it.

Someone will have to explain the Beck hate to me. I don't get it. Beck v2006 is one of the best QB's we've had.
________
Montana medical marijuana dispensaries

[jay santos]

Originally Posted by TheAzzuri

Someone will have to explain the Beck hate to me. I don't get it. Beck v2006 is one of the best QB's we've had.

I could probably be categorized as a Beck hater for his frosh - junior seasons. Though more accurately I would call myself a non-Beck-worshipper. I definitely changed my tune his senior year, especially after the two losses. He was brilliant and was playing at a level that could compare with ANY of the past greats.